Logo Refresh vs. Rebrand: What’s the Difference? - Paper Lime Creative
Logo Refresh vs. Rebrand: What’s the Difference?
Write By: Katie Dooley

You don’t always need to start over

You’ve been in business for a few years. Your logo feels dated and your marketing materials aren’t quite consistent. You now find yourself wondering if it’s time for an update, but you don’t know where to begin.

Do you need an updated logo? A branding refresh? Or do you need to start from scratch and do an entire rebrand?

A business can outgrow its visual identity without changing who it serves. However, sometimes the logo is only the most visible symptom of a much bigger branding problem.

Ask yourself: Do you need to change how your brand looks, or do you need to rethink the strategy underneath it?

When you can confidently answer that question, you’ll know whether a branding refresh or a rebrand is right for you. 

What is a brand refresh?

A refresh updates the way your existing brand shows up

A brand refresh is the right choice when the underlying business and strategy still work, but the visual identity no longer represents the business as well as it once did.

A brand refresh can take a few forms including updating the logo, changing your brand colours, selecting new brand fonts, or updating the photography style. You might need a brand refresh if you’re looking to create a more cohesive visual identity, improve your marketing materials or bring consistency to an otherwise piecemeal marketing strategy. 

Unlike a rebrand, a branding refresh doesn’t change who the business is, it is simply improving how the business is presenting itself. 

Your customers haven’t fundamentally changed

If you are confident knowing who your ideal customer is and you are still working with the same market, you don’t necessarily need to start over. You have simply gotten better at your business than your original branding anticipated.

You started your business with a DIY logo because you needed something to put on a business card. Five years later, you’re charging more, working with better clients and have a team supporting you. The business has evolved, but the customers you love serving are still the same. 

What is a rebrand?

A rebrand changes the strategy, not just the aesthetics

A rebrand may be necessary when the business has changed significantly, such as:

  • Your ideal customer has changed
  • Your services have changed substantially
  • You’ve entered a new market
  • Your positioning has changed
  • You’ve changed what makes your business different
  • Your pricing and level of service have changed dramatically
  • The business you want to build is significantly different from the one you originally created

These are instances where a new brand strategy and brand position are required. By simply updating your logo or changing your brand colours, you are not solving the problem of creating something that your ideal customer relates to. 

Sometimes the logo isn’t actually the problem

You might be thinking that you hate your logo, and that’s a valid feeling to have. But is it the real problem? Do you know who you’re trying to reach? What makes you different from your competitors? What is the true emotional transformation you provide your clients?

Without understanding these fundamentals of brand strategy, changing the logo is, like the saying goes, putting lipstick on a pig. 

It’s an amazing ‘problem’ to have when a businesses growth and success outpaces the branding. It can be challenging to navigate the changes of branding while also managing a growing business, especially if your services have changed, your team has grown, or if you’ve moved into a new market. 

Logo redesign vs. brand refresh vs. rebrand

We’ve gotten a lot of requests over the years to help businesses with their visual identity. These terms get used interchangeably, even though they mean different things. Often, clients come to us asking for a logo when what they really need is a full brand strategy. 

Logo redesign

A logo redesign has the smallest scope. It involves an update to the logo, while the brand strategy and other brand foundations remain untouched. 

This can include updates such as: 

  • Refining the typography
  • Simplifying the icon
  • Updating proportions
  • Modernizing an outdated design
  • Creating better logo variations

Brand refresh

A brand refresh is a medium scope package. This is a great option for businesses with stable audiences and established strategies, but where the visual identity that was originally created doesn’t match that audience or strategy. (This is often the 5am Canva logo before a networking event!) 

Updates in a brand refresh can include: 

  • Logo
  • Colours
  • Fonts
  • Photography
  • Supporting graphics
  • Brand guidelines
  • Marketing materials

Rebrand

A rebrand is the biggest change that involves a strategy overhaul. Once the strategy is in place, then the visual identity is developed to match. 

The rebrand process can include these steps: 

  • Ideal customer research
  • Positioning
  • Brand characteristics
  • Messaging
  • Competitive research
  • Logo
  • Colour palette
  • Typography
  • Photography direction
  • Supporting visual identity
  • Brand guidelines
  • Marketing collateral

Which one does your business need?

You might be hesitant when you think about the cost of a rebrand, or maybe you’re ready to throw the baby out with the bathwater and start from scratch. However, picking the right package for your needs is crucial to maintain familiarity in your market, protect your budget, and be thoughtful with your strategy.

You may need a logo redesign if:

  • You still love your overall brand
  • Your audience hasn’t changed
  • Your positioning still works
  • The logo feels dated, is difficult to use, or poorly designed
  • Your other brand elements are working well and building recognition and trust

You may need a brand refresh if:

  • Your business has grown
  • Your ideal customers are essentially the same
  • Your services have evolved but haven’t fundamentally changed
  • Your branding feels dated or inconsistent
  • Your marketing materials don’t feel like they belong together
  • Your visual identity doesn’t reflect the quality of your work anymore

You may need a rebrand if:

  • Your ideal customer has changed significantly
  • You never defined your when you started your marketing
  • Your services or business model have substantially changed
  • You’re not getting your ideal customers in the door
  • You aren’t clear about what makes your business different
  • The business you’re building looks very different from the business you originally branded

What happens if you choose the wrong one?

In my ten years in business I have learned that business owners are nothing if not frugal and strategic. I definitely do not want to oversell a client and put them in a package that they don’t need. However, I will encourage a bigger package if I see that there issue is bigger than an aesthetic one. I never want to give a client something that doesn’t work for them and provide an ROI. 

Here’s what can happen if you try to squeeze yourself into the wrong sized package. 

A rebrand when you only needed a refresh

Rebrands are a lot of fun, and it can definitely be tempting to start brand new. However, if you’ve been in business for a long time and like the clients you are working with, then an entirely new business brand can throw those loyal clients for a loop.

Rebranding in the short-term means there is a gap in brand recognition and therefore a dip in trust as well. Part of your rebranding strategy and the launch of your new visual identity should include a way to mitigate any potential confusion for your customers. 

It’s important not to throw away years of visibility just because you no longer like your logo. A functional brand brings in the right customers consistently and there is more value to your bottom line in that than you personally liking the business brand. 

A refresh when you actually need a rebrand

The biggest risk of spending too much money to get something done is that you spent too much money. The biggest risk of spending too little money on something is that you have spent the money and now it also doesn’t do what you need it to do. 

Just because a brand looks good, doesn’t mean that it’s doing its job. I had a Real Estate Agent tell me once that her favourite colour is purple. She also told me that she loves working for trades guys out of Fort McMurray where she grew up. I absolutely could’ve created a stunning purple brand for her. But for those oil field workers from Fort Mac? A purple logo would’ve repelled them instead of attracting them. Looking good is a result of good strategy, and what you think looks good might not be what your customers want. 

A pretty brand with bad strategy is still bad strategy.

Need help deciding if you need a business rebrand?

If you’re not sure whether your business needs a logo redesign, brand refresh or full rebrand, that’s exactly the kind of question we can help you answer. At Paper Lime Creative, we start with the business and the strategy before we start designing, so you’re investing in the changes your brand actually needs—not simply changing your logo because you’re tired of looking at it. Ready to figure out what’s next for your brand? Let’s talk.