Your business has changed, but your branding hasn’t
You started as a one-person show in a home office. These days, work looks a little bit different with your staff and office space. You’re even thinking about investing in a couple of company vehicles.
You’ve built systems and processes, hired and fired, and constantly gotten better at the work that you do. But, you’re starting to feel a mismatch between your business branding and the work you do.
The business branding that worked when you started may not work anymore
Think back to when you created your first logo. You spent a late night working in Canva, or ordered something on Fiverr not knowing what you wanted, or your buddy said he could whip something up for you. Either way, you needed a logo and you needed it quickly.
You weren’t even thinking about a full brand identity. You needed a logo, and that’s okay.
That first logo you made looks fine, but it isn’t keeping up with the growth of your business. Over time your services got more expensive and you started looking for a more discerning clientele.
You worry that your logo is starting to feel a bit cheap and generic. Outdated branding doesn’t mean it’s inherently wrong or bad. However, it’s important to have a brand that works: one that actively connects with customers, builds trust and reflects the business you’ve grown into.
7 signs your business has outgrown its branding
Here are seven signs your business has may need a rebrand or brand refresh.
1) You’re embarrassed to hand someone your business card
You’re ‘forgetting’ your business cards at the office. You apologize when you hand them out: “sorry, these are a bit old”. You’ve crossed out outdated information with a Sharpie. These are all signs that you’re not proud of your business card.
It should be exciting when someone asks for your business card. It means that you’ve piqued their interest enough that they want to remember you exist. Or, better yet, contact you or refer you in the future.
A business card is a first introduction and a constant reminder of who you are. It should be professional, memorable and reflective of your business branding. It can be one of the only things that keeps you top of mind after a brief introduction to a new contact.
Creating a unique business card not only makes it easy for people to get in touch with you, but it can be a great opportunity to show off your brand identity and the outstanding work that you do.
2) Your ideal clients have changed
Ideal clients can change drastically, especially in service-based businesses, as your business grows. You spend the first few years in business hoping for anyone to use your services, but with time, you learn who you love to do business with. Your ideal clients can change in many ways as you become more skilled at being a business owner. This can include their demographics and psychographics, income levels, or and industry specialization.
I know I wasn’t too picky with whom I worked in those first few years. But after working with clients that I truly enjoyed, I started to notice similarities between them. It’s not just the parts that made them great clients (easy to work with, happy to pay the invoice, etc). When I actually looked at their demographics and psychographics I noticed similarities there as well.
Demographics & Psychographics
Demographics are the defining characteristics of a given population including age, gender, income, occupation, education level and geographic location. Psychographics are traits based in psychology beliefs, values, ambitions, and interests. Being able to define and redefine your ideal customer based on their demographics and psychographics will give you a good idea if your brand strategy and visual identity need updating. If either of these changes drastically, chances are your brand needs an update as well.
One specific demographic that can shift your branding is your client’s income level (or if you’re B2B, a business’s revenue). Often as business owners become more skilled and experienced in their craft, they want to make more money as well, and targeting higher income levels is a great way to do this without having to increase the volume of work. This means creating a business logo that feels elevated and sophisticated to reflect the higher quality and higher pricing.
Lastly, specializing in a specific industry is also an area that can indicate that your business has outgrown its branding. After working in an industry for years, many business owners find their niche. That is, a specific subset of their ideal customer that they excel at helping. Niching can be an excellent way to stand out from your competitors and truly hone into the people you love helping. Working with one specific subgroup can open up many opportunities for a brand refresh because you’re able to use specific visuals and messaging to attract a very specific group of people.
Once you start recognizing these similarities, you can use that information to intentionally target your ideal customers with an effective brand identity.
Your services have changed
One of the best things about being a business owner is that you can change and adapt your service offerings as you see gaps in the market and receive consumer feedback. Being a SME means that you have the flexibility to innovate quickly without having to go through levels of management and board members.
Change can also happen in the form of industry advancements. The automotive industry looks vastly different than it did twenty years ago. Technology moves forward, supply and demand change, prices adjust, and customers have different expectations of your business.
This means that in two or three years, your business might be unrecognizable to what it was when you first started. You might’ve branded for one set of services that is no longer relevant, or you offer a variety of services that no longer fits into a pigeonholed business brand strategy.
Your business branding doesn’t reflect the quality of your work
You’ve likely heard “Cheap-Fast-Good, pick two” when it comes to products and services. Often, when businesses are starting out with their brand identity they pick cheap and fast. Start-ups don’t have a lot of extra money lying around, and they want to get the ball rolling quickly so that they can start earning revenue.
You want your brand strategy to reflect the type of services you offer. If you are a cheap/fast company, then opting business branding that feels cheap and fast is a great solution.
However, if you are any of the other combinations (cheap and good or fast and good) you’ll likely want to invest in branding that is the same. Many business owners will elevate their level of product or service as they become established experts in their industry. This means that DIY branding doesn’t match what is being provided to the customer. Chances are you need a brand strategist that is an established expert in their industry to help you achieve something that looks like it fits — professional branding that reflects the quality of work you’re actually doing.
Your marketing materials look like they came from different businesses
I have a story I like to tell about the time I couldn’t find the autobody shop I was meant to take my car to. The business owner and I had connected at a networking event, we had built rapport and I knew he would look after my auto body needs. I had his business card on my desk and it had everything I needed to book an appointment — phone number, email, and an address to take my vehicle to.
The business card was yellow and green (just like the Edmonton Elks) and I drove past the shop because the storefront awning was blue.
This is a perfect example of the cognitive load and how branding decisions make your customer’s life easier or harder. You might be thinking “Katie, why didn’t you just read the signage?”. Well, I was driving. At that point you’re doing a few things at once. I was watching the road and monitoring traffic to make sure that as I slowed down at various points that no one was frustrated behind me, and I’m looking for the visual cues the autobody shop had already trained me on — yellow and green. Did you know our brains process colour before words?
When our brains are already under stress and trying to process information, throwing in something like a colour difference makes it harder and therefore creates friction, frustration and mistrust. If your marketing materials, signage and other brand touchpoints don’t look like they belong to the same business, you’re making your customer work harder to recognize you.
You keep breaking your own branding rules.
Branding is a standard operating procedure. That means it should be easy to replicate and reproduce by anyone who comes in contact with your branding. Whether that’s your admin assistant ordering some new team jackets, or the vehicle wrap company designing some new decals for you.
When you start breaking your own brand rules, or making up new ones, it can be a signal that it’s time to refresh or rebrand your business. This breaks the SOP and leaves your team and your customers guessing on how you’re going to show up.
You’re no longer excited to send people to your website
“Under Construction”
“Coming Soon”
“404”
Those are the worst case scenarios that might make you cringe when someone asks for your website URL. But stale photos, old content writing, a non-responsive website, and outdated products and services can be a sure sign that your brand identity no longer matches where you’re at in your business.
Your website is where your brand identity, messaging and visual identity all come together and it should be a platform that gets you business, not something that you’re embarrassed about.
Does your business need a rebrand or a brand refresh?
It’s important to understand the difference between a brand refresh vs. a rebrand, and whether your business needs a full rebrand or a brand refresh. Doing a full rebrand unnecessarily can cause customer confusion and cost you money you don’t need to spend. However, if your strategy is not reaching your intended audience, then a brand refresh might not be enough!
Brand refresh
A brand refresh is when you have a well-defined ideal customer who is remaining the same. You understand why you love to work with them and how your product or service helps them. However, your logo, visual identity or branding isn’t communicating to them as well as it could.
A brand refresh is an excellent choice if you DIY’d your brand to begin with. You might have a deep understanding of who your customer is and their buying habits — but how does that translate into a brand colour or font? This is where partnering with an expert brand strategist can help bridge the gap between what you do and your visual identity. You don’t need to know what font represents your business best, leave that up to the brand strategist and help them by giving them the expertise you have in your industry.
Rebranding your business
A full rebrand is a great choice when you aren’t sure who your ideal customer is. If you find yourself at a variety of networking events and never find your client, or if some days you love the people you work with and then the next day you can’t stand them… Chances are you haven’t defined your ideal customer well enough. When you do know who your ideal customer is, 80% or more of the people you work with, you will love! And you’ll know exactly where to go to find them.
A business rebrand starts from scratch by redefining your ideal customer in great detail, and then building your brand strategy and visual identity from the ground up.
What happens when you don’t update your branding
Even the most consistent brands update their branding over time. No brand truly stays the same forever.
Coca-Cola is an excellent example of a long-lived brand that has mastered the balance between updating and staying consistent. Coca-Cola’s brand foundations (logo, colours, fonts, mission, vision and values) have remained the same for over 100 years. This is why you can walk into any grocery store in the world, and know you’re buying a Coca-Cola.
Where Coca-Cola has updated is in their marketing and advertising strategy. Messaging has stayed current with the times both in format and the language used. Photography and videography have been updated to reflect the times as well.
A rebrand should reflect where you’re going
Like with Coca-Cola, the longer you can maintain the same branding the more recognition, credibility and trust you will build. That’s why it’s so important to brand with where you want to take your business in mind. If you brand for the business you have now, then you’ll constantly be playing catch-up with your branding as you outgrow it year after year. Develop a brand for the business you want to have: your dream business with your dream customers. This will help ensure longevity in your branding, and help you achieve that dream business even faster.
Ready to talk about your branding?
If you’re ready to get rid of the embarrassment and update your branding, Paper Lime Creative can help. Let’s sit down and discuss your design needs and create an amazing brand that you and your clients will love! Book a call with us today!
